The difference between air-entraining agents and defoamers in concrete

About

	Our Company
	News

Products
	Concrete Admixtures

Mining Chemicals

Personal Care Ingredients

	Agricultural Fertilizers
	Food Additives
	Water Treatment Chemicals
	Other Chemicals

Findings
	New Product Notice
	Research Progress

Contact

info@surechemical.com

86-311-85697096

The difference between air-entraining agents and defoamers in concrete

_________________________________________________________________________

I. Mechanism of Action

1. Mechanism of action of air-entraining agents

Air-entraining agents are mostly anionic surfactants (such as rosin and alkylbenzene sulfonates), and their core function is to change the interfacial tension and bubble stability inside the concrete.

(1) It adsorbs at the cement slurry-water interface, reduces surface tension, and makes it easier for air to be drawn in and form micro bubbles during mixing.

(2) Molecules are oriented to form a "protective film" on the surface of the bubble, preventing the bubbles from merging or breaking, thus achieving a uniform (diameter 20-200μm) and closed distribution of the bubbles.

(3) Air bubbles fill the voids in the cement slurry, reducing bleeding and segregation. During freeze-thaw cycles, air bubbles act as a "buffer space," releasing the expansion stress of ice crystals and preventing concrete from cracking.

2. Mechanism of action of defoamers

Defoamers are mostly nonionic surfactants (such as silicones and polyethers), and their core function is to disrupt the stability of harmful bubbles and promote their collapse.

(1) Adsorbed on the surface of large bubbles (diameter > 200 μm), replacing the original stable molecules and destroying the integrity of the "protective film".

(2) Reduce the surface tension gradient of the bubble, causing the bubble film to become locally thinner and rupture, releasing the internal gas.

(3) It inhibits the generation of new harmful bubbles without affecting the tiny closed bubbles generated by the air-entraining agent , ultimately reducing large pores and surface defects inside the concrete.

II. Core Role

1. The core function of air-entraining agents

(1) Introduce tiny, stable and uniformly distributed closed air bubbles (20-200μm in diameter) into the concrete to improve workability (reduce bleeding segregation), enhance freeze-thaw resistance (air bubbles buffer freeze-thaw stress) and impermeability, while reducing the internal porosity of the concrete.

(2) Suitable for concrete (such as bridges and pavements) that is used in winter construction or exposed to freeze-thaw environments, or pumped concrete that requires high workability.

2. The core function of Defoamers

(1) harmful large air bubbles (diameter > 200 μm) generated during concrete mixing and pouring , avoid surface defects such as honeycomb, pitting, and air holes, and improve concrete density and appearance quality.

(2) It is often used in combination with air-entraining agents (to counteract the effects of excessive air bubbles) and is suitable for scenarios with high requirements for surface flatness and density, such as fair-faced concrete and decorative concrete.

III. Comparison of the core differences between air-entraining agents and defoamers

Air-entraining agents "actively create beneficial small bubbles," while defoamers "passively break up harmful large bubbles." Their actions are opposite and their functions are complementary. The specific differences are as follows:

Comparison Dimensions	Entraining agent	Defoamer
Core Objectives	Introducing closed microbubbles of 20-200μm	harmful large air bubbles >200μm
Functional properties	Actively generate and stabilize beneficial bubbles; passively destroy and suppress harmful bubbles.	Effects on bubbles: Increases bubble count (increases gas content); Decreases bubble count (reduces ineffective gas content ).
Main effects	Improve workability, enhance freeze-thaw resistance and impermeability	Increase density and optimize surface appearance (avoid honeycomb-like texture ) .
Applicable Scenarios	Freeze-thaw environment, winter construction, pumped concrete	Fair-faced concrete, finished concrete, and components with high aesthetic requirements
Collocation	Commonly used as a basic admixture	It is often used in combination with air-entraining agents (to counteract the negative effects of excessive bubbles).

IV. Optimal Dosage of Air-entraining agents and Defoamers in Concrete

There is no fixed optimal dosage for air-entraining agents and defoamers. Common dosages in concrete fall within a general range, but adjustments must be made based on concrete type and performance requirements. Below are general dosage data for both in concrete and for special scenarios:

1. Entraining agent:

The general dosage is 0.005%-0.02% of the cement mass. In special scenarios, the optimal dosage in C50 fair-faced concrete for bridges is 5×10^-5 of the mother liquor; when self-compacting fair-faced concrete is compounded with polycarboxylate superplasticizer, the optimal dosage is 0.16‰; when used in combination with a specific defoamer for box girder concrete, the concrete performance is optimal at a dosage of 0.01%.

2. Defoamer:

The general dosage is 10%-50% of the air-entraining agents's mass. In special scenarios, for bridge piers and columns using C30 or C40 fair-faced concrete, the optimal dosage is 8×10^-4 of the mother liquor; when self-compacting fair-faced concrete is compounded with polycarboxylate superplasticizer, the optimal dosage is 0.50‰; in box girder concrete, a dosage of 0.1% can be combined with the air-entraining agents to achieve optimal concrete performance.

Causes and countermeasures of several common concrete cracks

Essential Questions and Answers in the Application of Polycarboxylate Superplasticizers

Precautions for the application of polycarboxylate superplasticizers (Technical details)

Application of Silica Fume in Concrete from the Perspective of Its Mechanism of Action

The Role of Silica Fume in Concrete-Optimizing Microstructure, Enhancing Macro Performance

14 Must-See Products at the Upcoming Concrete Show South America 2025

The Impact of Silica Fume on Concrete Performance

Silica fume (microsilica) as a Concrete Admixture

The Role of Silica Fume in UHPC

2fcl Microsilica as a trial order to South America market

Wide uses in the refractory industry of silica fume

Introduction of Cement Content-reducing Admixture (II): Technical Analysis of Cement Content-Reducing Admixtures